Meditation is often praised as a life-changing practice that reduces stress, improves focus, and fosters emotional well-being. But with all those positive attributes, can meditation cause depression? While most people experience benefits, some report unexpected emotional distress, like anxiety, sadness, and even depressive symptoms.
This raises an important question: Can meditation have unintended negative effects? And if so, why does this happen? In this article, we’ll take a look at how meditation can sometimes lead to depression, who might be at risk, and how to practice safely.
How Can Meditation Cause Depression?
Understanding the Controversy
Meditation is generally associated with positive mental health and well being. But recent studies and personal accounts suggest that it may contribute to feelings of depression. Some meditators report experiencing a question of purpose or increased rumination.
While meditation itself isn’t inherently harmful, its effects depend on various factors such as the practitioner’s mental health, the type of meditation, and the duration of practice. Understanding why this happens is crucial to experience a healthy and beneficial meditation.
Scientific Studies on Meditation and Depression
While research overwhelmingly supports the mental health benefits of meditation, some studies have shown that it can also have unintended psychological effects.
- A 2017 study published in PLOS ONE found that 25% of participants experienced negative effects from meditation, including increased anxiety and emotional distress.
- Another study in Translational Psychiatry suggested that intensive meditation retreats might trigger traumatic memories or psychological discomfort in some individuals.
- However, research also confirms that meditation reduces stress and enhances emotional regulation for most people, showing that individual experiences vary widely.
So, if meditation is meant to improve well-being, why does it sometimes lead to negative and depressive feelings?
Why Might Meditation Lead to Depression?
1. Suppressed Emotions Resurfacing
One of the most common reasons meditation can feel unsettling is that it’s bringing up suppressed emotions. Many of us go through life avoiding painful feelings, but meditation creates an opportunity for unresolved emotions to surface.
- Memories of past trauma or unprocessed grief may arise.
- This emotional release can feel overwhelming, especially without guidance.
- Without a support system, some people may feel lost in their emotions rather than being able to move forward and heal.
While emotional processing is a natural and necessary part of deep self-awareness, it can be difficult to navigate and handle without support.
2. Over-Identification with Thoughts
Meditation increases self-awareness, but it can also lead to overanalyzing thoughts. This can be especially hazardous for those who easily fall into negative thinking. Instead of detaching from negative thoughts, some people may become more attached to them.
- People with anxiety or depression may already struggle with rumination (repetitive negative thinking).
- Meditation, when practiced without guidance, can sometimes intensify this habit, creating the thought to repeat over and over.
- Instead of feeling more at peace, the practitioner may end up feeling stuck in self-criticism.
This is why mindfulness meditation, when not practiced correctly, can have the opposite of its intended effect. One must be mindful of the correct thought.
3. Isolation and Withdrawal
Many serious meditators may spend long hours in solitude, which can sometimes lead to social withdrawal. While the occasional alone time is beneficial, excessive isolation can bring forth feelings of loneliness and disconnection.
- Deep introspection can make external relationships feel less important and insignificant.
- Some meditators feel detached from social norms and struggle to reintegrate into daily life.
- Remember, social interaction is crucial for mental health, and meditation should complement, not replace, human connection.
4. Meditation-Induced Dissociation
Some individuals report feeling emotionally numb or disconnected from reality after prolonged meditation. This phenomenon is sometimes linked to depersonalization and derealization disorders.
- Certain meditation techniques (e.g., Vipassana or Zen) emphasize detachment from emotions, which can feel unsettling for those who are unprepared.
- If practiced excessively, meditation may create a sense of detachment from one’s identity or surroundings.
- Instead of achieving peace, some may feel like they are watching life happen rather than living it.
Dissociation can be particularly challenging for those with preexisting mental health conditions, as it may worsen feelings of emptiness.
5. Unstructured or Excessive Practice
Like any mental exercise, too much meditation too soon can lead to mental fatigue. Meditation should be gradual and intentional, not forced or excessive.
- Meditating for hours without being prepared can overwhelm the nervous system.
- Some meditation retreats encourage extended practice that may be too intense for beginners.
- Instead of feeling enlightened, some people may feel mentally exhausted or emotionally drained.
For beginners, starting small and gradually increasing the length of your session is key to avoiding burnout.
Who Is at Risk?
1. Individuals with Preexisting Mental Health Conditions
People with anxiety, depression, PTSD, or other mental health challenges may find that meditation intensifies their emotions rather than soothes them.
- Meditation is not a substitute for therapy but can complement it.
- Those with past trauma may need trauma-informed meditation techniques to help avoid distressing flashbacks.
- Consulting a mental health professional before starting a deep meditation practice would be extremely beneficial and is strongly recommended.
2. Those Practicing Without Proper Guidance
Having some guidance matters. Meditating without proper instruction can lead to confusion or wasted time.
- Beginners may find it more beneficial to start with structured programs rather than self-guided meditation.
- Working with an experienced teacher can help navigate emotional challenges and creates an opportunity to address any questions that arise.
- Meditation apps, books, and online courses can be very useful, but nothing can truly replace professional guidance when needed.
3. People with Perfectionist or Obsessive Traits
Some individuals turn meditation into a rigid goal-oriented task, which can be counterproductive.
- The paradox of meditation: Forcing relaxation can create stress.
- Perfectionists may get frustrated if they don’t experience immediate benefits.
- Letting go of expectations is key to a healthy meditation practice.
How to Meditate Safely and Avoid Negative Effects
1. Start Slowly and Observe Your Reactions
Try starting with just 5 to 10 minutes. This gentle approach allows you to ease into the practice without feeling overwhelmed. Keeping a meditation journal can be incredibly helpful during this time, as it allows you to track your emotional responses and notice any patterns that emerge.
2. Seek Professional Guidance When Needed
A therapist or an experienced meditation teacher can help you navigate challenges and adjust your practice in a way that supports your mental health. For those struggling with persistent negative thoughts, incorporating mindfulness-based cognitive therapy (MBCT) might be especially helpful. Additionally, resources like The Center for Healthy Minds offer valuable research and guidance on fostering mindful well-being, providing extra support as you continue your journey.
3. Balance Meditation with Other Activities
Balancing meditation with physical activities like yoga or mindful walking can enhance both your mental and physical well-being. It’s also important to nurture social connections—spending time with friends, family, or engaging in group activities can provide a sense of belonging and support.
4. Use the Right Meditation Techniques
Guided meditations are often a great option for beginners, providing structure and support as you learn to quiet the mind. Mindfulness practices that focus on gratitude or self-compassion can also be particularly helpful in easing negative thoughts and fostering a more positive mindset. Don’t be afraid to experiment with different techniques to discover what feels most natural and effective for you.
5. Recognize When to Take a Break
If your practice starts to feel overwhelming or emotionally draining, it’s perfectly okay to step back and give yourself some space. Trust your intuition and prioritize your mental well-being. Your practice should support and nourish you, not add to your stress.
Meditation is a powerful tool, but like any mental practice, it affects individuals differently. While it generally enhances well-being, some people may experience depressive symptoms due to resurfacing emotions, over-identification with thoughts, excessive introspection and the like.
Understanding these risks allows for an informed approach to meditation. By starting slowly, seeking guidance, and practicing self-awareness, you can reap the benefits of meditation while avoiding its potential pitfalls.
————————————————————————————————————————
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)
Meditation is generally seen as a positive practice, but for some, it can bring up unexpected emotional challenges. If you’ve ever felt depressed, anxious, or unsettled after meditating, you’re not alone. Below are answers to some common questions about the negative effects meditation may have and how to navigate them safely.
1. Can meditation make you feel depressed?
Yes, meditation can sometimes bring up feelings of depression, especially if it uncovers suppressed emotions or triggers past trauma. Instead of immediately feeling calm, some may experience sadness or emotional discomfort as unresolved feelings rise to the surface. This is a normal part of emotional processing, but if meditation consistently worsens your mood, consider practicing with some professional guidance.
2. Can meditation have negative effects?
While meditation is generally beneficial, it can have negative effects for some people. Potential downsides include:
- Increased rumination or overthinking, especially in those with anxiety or depression.
- Emotional detachment or dissociation if practiced excessively.
- Social withdrawal due to deep introspection leading to feelings of isolation. These effects are more likely if meditation is practiced without proper structure or guidance.
3. Why do I feel negative after meditation?
Feeling negative after meditation can be due to several reasons:
- Emotional release: Meditation brings up buried emotions that can feel overwhelming.
- Over-focusing on thoughts: Instead of letting thoughts pass, you may unconsciously cling to negative ones.
- Expectations vs. reality: If you expect instant calm but experience discomfort, frustration can arise. If this happens, try shorter, guided meditations or mindfulness exercises that focus on gratitude or self-compassion.
4. Can meditation worsen anxiety?
Yes, for some individuals, meditation can make anxiety worse, especially in the early stages. This happens because meditation makes you more aware of your thoughts and emotions, including the anxious ones. If you have severe anxiety, start with shorter sessions (5–10 minutes) and try techniques like guided meditations or breathwork instead of silent meditation, which might feel overwhelming.
5. How can I meditate safely to avoid negative effects?
To meditate safely and minimize negative experiences:
- Start with short sessions and gradually increase time.
- Use guided meditations if silent meditation feels overwhelming.
- Seek professional guidance if you have past trauma or severe mental health concerns.
- Balance meditation with movement and social interactions to stay grounded. If meditation continues to feel distressing, consider taking a break or consulting a mindfulness expert for tailored advice.
- Integrate your meditation with movement such as yoga, tai chi or qigong
Have you ever experienced unexpected emotions—whether positive or negative—during meditation? How did you handle it? Please share your experience in the comments below!
